Sign up for my monthly newsletter
Self-help vs shelf-help: how to make personal development stick.
As you'd expect from a coach, I work my way through a lot of self-help content. Books, videos, courses, podcasts, you name it, I'm on it.
The self-help industry has boomed in the past decade, with an estimated 15,000 books published each year and more than 200,000 podcasts on Apple alone.
At the bottom of that huge pile you'll find some entertainingly ridiculous stuff: kitchen psychology mixed with pseudo-science and enough quantum physics to confuse Stephen Hawking, all designed to help you 'manifest' your dreams. What's genius about those books is that you only get to blame yourself whenever their advice doesn't work. You just have to 'attract' a little harder next time.
A little further up the pile you'll find books with great ideas that get lost in a sea of endless anecdotes, usually because the author was pressured to write 180 pages. But at the very top you'll find the content that genuinely shifts your perspective. That's the kind of self-help I want to talk about here, because it deserves more than being consumed. It deserves to be studied.
The student vs the consumer
I've often made the classic mistake of believing that reading or viewing equals learning. It doesn't. True learning comes through deliberate practice, for which there's a simple formula:
Action x Reflection = Learning
'Action' means acquiring and applying behaviours in new ways and situations. 'Reflection' means opening a second track in your mind where you consciously test the impact of whatever you're trying to adopt, then spending a few minutes afterwards assessing whether it worked or what you'd do differently. Deliberate practice means repeating that sequence over and over. Without that feedback loop, you simply won't learn.
Say you're working on becoming a more emotionally resonant leader. No matter how many books or masterclasses you take on vulnerability and emotional intelligence, you won't magically become a better one. Unless you actively test new ways of being around your team, reflect on what went well, and run the loop again and again, your colleagues will just think you're the same person, except now you sound a little more like Oprah.
Tips for making self-help stick
In case my sarcasm made you wonder, I genuinely love the genre, and even lousy content usually has a nugget worth keeping. The content that speaks to me may not speak to you, so I've deliberately not included any reading suggestions here. Given the topic, I figured you can help yourself. Here are six tips for integrating what you learn.
Tip 1: Switch to short-form reading
Many self-help books are far too long, spinning two or three good ideas across dozens of tedious digressions. Book-summary services distil the essentials into a readable ten-page outline you can listen to or print. It's an excellent way to get the core ideas without the padding. And yes, there's some irony in using an article to criticise authors for being too wordy.
Tip 2: Take notes and summarise
Turn reading time into study time. Pause a video or podcast and write down whatever concept resonates. Highlight passages and export them. When you finish a chapter or book, spend a few minutes summarising the key takeaways for you. By actively engaging with the content, you're far more likely to retain it. A friend of mine does this beautifully by hand, condensing the books he's read and his therapy sessions into notebooks that give him a snapshot of where he's at and a timeline of his growth.
Tip 3: Set specific goals
Put boundaries around how much self-help you consume. Instead of clicking every suggested video or buying every attractive cover in the airport bookshop, get strategic about your intake. Decide where you want to develop, then curate a focused set of books, articles and content on that one area, and spend a season learning from the best.
Tip 4: Pick your favourite three learnings and integrate them
This is the most useful tip of all. For each book you read, identify the three insights that resonated most. Then spend the next couple of weeks finding opportunities to put each into practice. Don't try to implement everything at once. Pick three and practise the hell out of them in real life. Only once you've genuinely integrated them should you move on to your next book.
Tip 5: Read more novels
The underlying message of personal development is that there's always something to improve, which quietly reinforces the belief that we're never quite good enough. There's a parallel with the medical health paradox: the more help patients receive, the more they self-diagnose and the worse they often feel. The psychologist Svend Brinkmann, a self-help critic, suggests we turn back to fiction and poetry, because, as he puts it, "they take you away from yourself rather than make you focus even more on yourself."
Tip 6: Be critical
As James Clear once wrote: "One sign you haven't done enough reading is if you find yourself agreeing with whatever book you read last." Don't limit yourself to one book or author. Combine learnings from multiple sources, form your own opinion, and decide for yourself where to direct your practice. A book selling millions of copies is no guarantee it isn't utter rubbish.
The power of how
We've made real strides in speaking openly about mental health, emotional intelligence and personal development, and we owe a great deal of that to the self-help industry. Just remember that consuming the content is like throwing spaghetti at a wall to see what sticks. That isn't how behavioural change works. Choose your content carefully, study it, and integrate it through deliberate practice. Only then will it actually change anything.
← All articles